Skip to main content

Lorio Forensics

Sex Crime Cases: The Potential Advantages of Psychosexual Evaluations

Sex crime cases can be among the most complex in criminal litigation. They are often emotionally charged and carry a unique stigma – for the offender and the offended. How to accurately assess the client, future risks, and work towards resolution requires far more than fact finding. And Lorio Forensics consultants have specialized expertise in psychosexual evaluation.

Forensic mental health evaluators, and by extension their evaluation process, can be impacted by the stigma associated with sex crimes. “Moving beyond stigma starts with approaching these cases as you would any other clinical or legal matter: with objectivity, curiosity, and a focus on gathering accurate information,” according to Licensed Psychologist Dr. Charice Williams, an Associate Consultant with Lorio Forensics. Dr. Williams has worked extensively with people convicted of sex crimes. She adds, “The clinician’s role is not to judge or react to the behavior, but to understand it thoroughly and assess the relevant facts. Strong clinical interviewing skills allow you to remain neutral and focused on the information needed to formulate appropriate conclusions and recommendations.” The goal for experts is to understand first; no differently than any other behavior. 

Few are eager to disclose sexual deviancy, creating immense challenges for all parties involved when it is an issue in the case. Speaking candidly about sexual attraction towards children, for example, is profoundly rare. There is a high likelihood that offenders might obscure or withhold the truth altogether, even when speaking privately to their own counsel. Navigating that challenge isn’t easy. “When working with clients who may be hesitant to disclose sensitive sexual interests or behaviors, the foundation is rapport,” according to Dr. Williams. “Just as with any other legal or clinical matter, people are more likely to be honest when they feel they are being approached without judgment. Using an open, curious, and non-accusatory style of questioning—and being comfortable discussing sensitive topics without reacting with shock or judgment—can make it easier for clients to be transparent. Ultimately, this is a clinical skill that comes with experience.”

Objective, psychological testing can be highly informative in these circumstances as well. This is especially true when considering the question of future risk. Experienced forensic clinicians can use validated and empirically informed approaches to evaluate risk factors, protective factors, treatment needs, and other variables relevant to the individual case. Risk assessment is an established area of forensic mental health practice, with specialized instruments and research addressing sexual offending and recidivism. This can give attorneys something more valuable than a general clinical opinion: a structured, evidence-based assessment that can be explained and defended.

Psychosexual cases often contain psychological and behavioral evidence that may not be obvious from the legal record – or even a general, standard mental health treatment. A forensic mental health expert can help counsel identify clinically significant information, understand competing explanations, evaluate the strengths and limitations of the available evidence, and determine what additional information may be necessary. That perspective can inform case strategy, plea negotiations, sentencing, treatment, supervision, and expert testimony. Not every mental health professional is qualified to conduct a sophisticated psychosexual evaluation. These cases require specialized knowledge of sexual behavior, forensic assessment, risk assessment, and the scientific literature surrounding sexual offending. In fact, the American Psychological Association’s current Handbook of Forensic Psychology treats sexual offending and risk assessment as distinct areas of forensic specialization. Lorio Forensics provides attorneys with objective, evidence-based expertise designed to address the complex mental health issues that arise in these high-stakes criminal matters.

Share Post:

Stay Connected