Mental Illness Awareness Week is October 5 – 11, a perfect time to ask the questions: Who knows they could benefit from mental health treatment? And who can get it? In 2024, an estimated 61.5 million American adults experienced a mental illness. Yet NIMH reports that only about half of people with mental illnesses receive treatment. That gap matters to the legal system. Millions of Americans have health insurance, established relationships with physicians, and the ability to seek medical care when something is wrong. But a disproportionate amount of individuals involved in the justice system have lived in an entirely different healthcare reality.
A person may have never had access to a psychiatrist or psychologist. They may never have received a formal diagnosis. They may have learned to live with symptoms without recognizing them as symptoms at all. They may not have a treatment history because there was no treatment to document, for many reasons. People may lack insurance or money. They may face transportation or other practical barriers. They may distrust the healthcare system. Stigma may discourage them from seeking help. Some may not believe they have a mental health problem in the first place. Research on untreated, serious mental illness has identified each of these factors as barriers to care. The forensic implications are significant.
The absence of a prior psychiatric diagnosis is not necessarily evidence of the absence of psychiatric symptoms that would constitute one. A client who arrives in an attorney’s office or docket who denies a history of mental illness may actually be denying a history of mental health treatment. They can still have a mental health condition that is shaping their thoughts, feelings, and/or behaviors in highly influential ways. And given that those who are court involved, particularly in criminal and family courts, have significantly higher trauma burdens than the general population, their risk of mental illness is elevated; not only for PTSD related disorders, but for mood, anxiety, even psychotic disorders. People who are from marginalized groups, be it by race or income level, are at even higher risk of undiagnosed mental illness.
Mental Illness Awareness Week should remind us that untreated mental illness is common, driven by societal inequities, and often an untold, but potentially pivotal, part of the story.



